November 16, 2023
Lekker Architects Offers a Fresh Approach to Inclusive Design
Behind this colossal endeavor lies none other than Lekker Architects, a local studio founded by husband-and-wife duo Ong Ker-Shing and Joshua Comaroff. Over the past decade, the duo, who also teach architecture at the National University of Singapore and urban studies at Yale-NUS College, have built a strong reputation for inclusive design have built a strong reputation for inclusive design. Today, they boast an impressive portfolio of projects including Singapore’s first inclusive preschool, a hospice daycare center, a quiet room in an art museum for people with sensory processing disorders, and a much-needed guide to dementia-friendly design, which they created in collaboration with Studio Lanzavecchia + Wai.
At FI&LD, Lekker picked out one particularly poignant quote by Paley: “If someone can’t play, you have to change the game.” The thesis was simple—if a game doesn’t work for everyone, then it must be redesigned—and it set the tone not only for the exhibition, but for the field of inclusive design more broadly. If blind people can’t use certain kitchen utensils, we must redesign them. If a subway car isn’t fit for neurodivergent people, we should design one that is.
For Lekker, inclusivity is a spectrum, and designing for inclusivity means striking a balance between no rules (which is just confusing) and too many rules (which is guaranteed to exclude someone.) The key, says Comaroff, is to design spaces that have the flexibility to adapt and allow people with contrasting needs to coexist in the same space.
This doesn’t just mean throwing your doors wide open and letting everyone in. “That works great until you design an inclusive school, and you actually sit down with inclusive educators,” he says. “These kids have radically contradictory needs. One kid with autism has hypersensitivity, the other [kid with autism] has hyposensitivity and needs background noise, visual stimulus, constant engagement. And those kids have to occupy the same space.”
One (wrong) solution might be to just build enough separate rooms to cater for people with various needs, but the kids wouldn’t interact or learn about each other’s differences. At the Kindle Garden preschool, for example, the architects designed an accessibility path on the floor that looks like a computer circuit and is made of a vinyl that is different from the rest of the floor so you could feel the difference when you walk on it barefoot. When the school first opened in 2015, Comaroff says there were no kids with visual impairments, so the path was seen as a fun decorative feature. Then a blind girl joined, and once the educators showed her how to navigate on the path, everybody else started walking on the line alongside her. “You see over and over again that kids try and minimize uncomfortable differences between each other,” says Comaroff. “And if there are differences, they just kind of ignore them; it’s an amazing form of empathy that they learn and if we separate them, they’re not going to get that.”
Over the course of their career, the architects have learned to design not just “expecting misuse,” as Ong puts it, but encouraging it by designing spaces and experiences that act less as prescribed models and more as prompts. For Singapore Design Week, Lekker also designed a web app called Play Play, which is a game generator that lets you set parameters that suit players with various needs or disabilities, then proposes games that fit those parameters. You can choose to play without looking, speaking, or using arms or legs, and if a new person enters the game, you can go back to the menu and change the rules so that everyone is on a level playing field from the get-go.
Vivian Paley likely would’ve been proud.
Would you like to comment on this article? Send your thoughts to: [email protected]
- No tags selected
Embracing Differences: Understanding and Designing for Neurodiversity
When we design for neurodiversity—be it autism, ADHD, sensory processing disorder—we design for everyone.
When We Design for Autism, We Design for Everyone
Magda Mostafa, autism design consultant and architecture professor at the American University in Cairo, discusses inclusive design.
Emma Weaver Designs for (and with) Empathy
This member of the 2023 Metropolis Future100 says her mission is to tell people’s stories through the interiors they inhabit.